Jerusalem Center for Social & Economic Rights

Jerusalem Center for Social & Economic Rights

ANNUAL REPORT 2000 

 


ANNUAL REPORT 2000

Contents

Preface

Our second annual report aims to describe the Israeli inhuman practices against Palestinians in East Jerusalem in explicit violation of international laws and conventions, as well as international legitimate resolutions pertaining to Occupied Arab Jerusalem.

Cases that were and continue to be defended by the Center constitute a clear example of the Israeli arbitrary policy in East Jerusalem. This policy is clearly manifested in the oppression of Palestinian Jerusalemites, denial of their social and humanitarian rights, and placing them under overwhelming difficulties with the aim of forcing them out of their homeland as part of implementing the far-reaching policy of ethnic cleansing programmed by the Israelis.

This report constitutes strong condemnation of the Israeli crimes committed against Palestinians in East Jerusalem and aims to highlight the lies and deception of the Zionist media, which claims that Israel is regarded as the most democratic state in the Middle East. This report indisputably proves that the state of Israel practices a policy of racial discrimination against Palestinian citizens in East Jerusalem.

The report also examines Israeli violations of the 1949 Fourth Geneva Convention pertaining to areas under the Israeli military occupation and also calls for ensuring international protection for the Palestinian people in the Palestinian territories occupied in June 1967, first and foremost Arab East Jerusalem.

This report is a call for human rights organizations and other international organizations to investigate Israel's violations of international laws and conventions and other human rights violations committed against Palestinian Jerusalemites.

We hope that this report would be a cry echoing in the ears of those who are deceived by the policy of the Israeli media. We also hope that it would not be a cry in a barren wilderness.

Ziad Al-Hammouri
Director
JCSER

Jerusalem Center for Social & Economic Rights

The Jerusalem Center for Social & Economic Rights (JCSER) is a Palestinian human rights non-governmental organization. Based in East Jerusalem, JCSER was established in late 1997 by a group of Palestinian lawyers and individuals concerned with Jerusalem and human rights issues. JCSER was established with the aim of:

In order to ensure the protection of the rights of Palestinian Jerusalemites, JCSER:
Monitors and documents human rights violations committed against Palestinians in East Jerusalem:

  • Monitors and documents human rights violations committed against Palestinians in East Jerusalem;

  • Provides free legal aid services to Palestinians;

  • Publishes scientific studies and research dealing with the social and economic conditions of Palestinian Jerusalemites;

  • Raises public awareness concerning existing laws and international human rights laws and conventions.

JCSER provides victims of Israeli violations the right to defend themselves in various Israeli courts and provides legal representation through its lawyers or through delegated lawyers from abroad. The Center ensures the protection of citizens' rights to residency, citizenship, housing, work, medical treatment, education, freedom of movement, and guarantees benefits and allowances to which Palestinian citizens are entitled from the National Insurance Institute (NII) and the Jerusalem Municipality. JCSER deals with cases related to Israel's policy of house demolition, ID card confiscation and denial of citizenship and residency rights in Jerusalem. It also deals with Israel's unfair discriminatory policy of the Arnona tax imposed on Palestinian Jerusalemites without taking into consideration the various income levels and social differences between East Jerusalem and West Jerusalem.

JCSER has undertaken experimental cases to be submitted to Israeli courts, including the Supreme Court, and established legal precedents on the social and economic conditions of Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem.

The Center organizes special visits to the Holy Land consisting of international and legal delegations and human rights observers with the aim of investigating Israeli human rights violations committed against Palestinians in East Jerusalem, and exerting pressure on the international community to end Israeli inhuman practices. Such practices constitute grave violations of international laws and conventions pertaining to the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT), including East Jerusalem.

The Center organizes and participates in local and international conferences and workshops that address Israeli human rights violations and aims to disclose these violations in order to emphasize the need to implement international laws and conventions and legitimate resolutions related to human rights in Jerusalem for being part of the occupied territories.

JCSER is an effective member of:

  • The Jerusalem Coalition against House Demolition;

  • The Coalition for the Defense of Jerusalem;

  • The Coalition to Stop ID Card Confiscation from Palestinian Jerusalemites;

  • The Coalition for Education;

  • The Land Defense Committees.

Introduction

Since the occupation of East Jerusalem in June 1967, the city and its residents have been subjected to an Israeli illegal discriminatory policy violating basic human rights. The policy aims at dedicating coercive annexation of the city and clearing out the city of its original inhabitants through ethnic cleansing, racial discrimination and denying citizenship and residency rights. Throughout 33 years of occupation, Israel's polices aimed at changing the legal, geographical, demographic, economic and administrative status of the Holy City. ,p> JCSER was established in 1997 with the aim of confronting Israel's discriminatory practices against Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem, defending their rights, and providing free legal aid services.

In its second annual report, covering the period between 1 September 1999 and 31 December 2000, JCSER sheds light on human rights violations committed by Israel against Palestinian citizens. Such practices constitute grave violations of international human rights conventions and laws. This report also presents different cases in which local residents were provided with free legal aid and outlines activities carried out by the Center during the mentioned period.

Israeli violations in occupied East Jerusalem

Following the occupation of Arab East Jerusalem on 5 June 1967, Israel declared the annexation of Jerusalem on 28 June 1967. Following its annexation, Israel took a number of measures with the aim of tightening its control over East Jerusalem and its Arab residents. Tens of thousands of Palestinians were forcibly expelled from their homes. Tens of thousands of Palestinians were unable to return, as a result of the Israeli aggression against Palestinian Jerusalemites.

Following the occupation of East Jerusalem and its annexation in June 1967, Israel launched its first demolition and ethnic cleansing campaign when the Israeli occupation troops demolished the neighborhoods of As-Sharaf and Al-Magharbeh to build Jewish settlements in their place. Original inhabitants were expelled from their homes. At that time, the Israeli government carried out its first operation, which involved the expansion of the municipal boundaries of Jerusalem in synch with the annexation declaration, which was followed by the annexation of 70,500 dunums of the land of East Jerusalem to the Jewish side of Jerusalem. The government imposed its own regulations, in accordance with an orchestrated racist policy, on the city and its legitimate inhabitants. The policy aimed at:

This has formed the core of Israel's policy in Jerusalem over 33 years of occupation with the aim of 'Judaizing' the Holy City and imposing the reality of coercive annexation. Violations committed by the Israeli government against Palestinian residents in the Holy City have diversified.

Most prominent violations committed Against Arab Residents In East Jerusalem

I. Confiscation of Properties & Coercive annexation of Jerusalem

Israeli successive governments, including the current government, have continued to expropriate Arab land and properties in East Jerusalem in many illegal ways, which are based on the superiority of the occupying country and its regulations in explicit violation of international laws and conventions. At least, 34% of the land of Jerusalem has been confiscated by the Israeli occupation authorities to build new and expand existing Jewish settlements, and 52% declared 'green area' where construction is forbidden for Arab Palestinians. However, 'green area' remains a strategic reserve for present and future settlement activities. Throughout the years, Israel did not hesitate to use this reserve for settlement expansion and construction as in the case of the Jewish settlement of Jabal Abu Ghneim 'Har Homa', the settlement of Ghib'at Ha Shu'fat and other settlements. The settlement construction is carried out not only at the expense of Arab properties, but also at the expense of Palestinian housing needs. Palestinian Jerusalemites are denied housing rights, as a result of the Israeli restrictive policies in the city.

The Israeli government has imposed property tax on privately owned properties, including properties, which have not been exploited by its owners, or on properties that owners have not used due to:

  • Financial difficulties;

  • Military orders banning construction;;

  • Problems related to settlement of inheritance;;

  • High costs of building; ;

  • Difficulties in obtaining building permits from the Israeli government;;

  • Restrictions imposed by Israel concerning building permits.;

Property tax was imposed retroactively on landowners. If the landowner was unable to pay the tax, the Israeli government filed a case against him and put the real estate for auction in favor of Jewish settlements. This has been the case in the northern and southern parts of Jerusalem.

The Israeli government confiscated 34% of the land of Jerusalem under the pretext of 'public interest'. An estimated 15 Jewish settlements were built on the confiscated land, nine industrial zones, and a hundred factories for light and heavy industries. Large numbers of properties have been confiscated in Jerusalem and its suburbs, through Israeli official institutions, to accommodate fascist and extremist groups. These properties belonged to individual, Islamic Waqf, Christian Waqf and public properties (state or municipality).

Throughout 33 years of occupation, Israel launched three expansion campaigns involving the municipal boundaries of Jerusalem in order to pave the way for the 'Judaization' of the Holy City and emptying the city of its original inhabitants. The first campaign was carried out following the Israeli occupation of East Jerusalem in June 1967, in which it became 70.5 square km2. The second took place in 1982 in what was called 'The Center Project', while the third expansion was part of the 'Greater Jerusalem' or the 'Metropolitan Plan', which was endorsed by the Israeli government on 28 June 1998. The Plan aimed primarily at expanding the municipal boundaries of Jerusalem and linking surrounding Jewish settlements together in a way to enable Israel to swallow up more land to build new Jewish neighborhoods. According to the 'Greater Jerusalem Plan', Israel swallows up parts of the heart of the West Bank up to Jericho eastwards and Ramallah northwards and the northern part of the governorate of the West Bank city of Hebron. The municipal boundaries of Jerusalem will be expanded to become 665 square km2. The aerial maps of the bypass road show that these villages are isolated from each other, whereas Jewish settlements built on the borders of Jerusalem are linked together. Reports have shown that the Israeli company, Moriah, has completed preparing the structural plans for the bypass road, which starts from the Jerusalem-Hebron road in the northern crossroads of 'Talpiot', passes through the village of Sur Baher, Sawahreh Al-Gharbiya and Sawahreh Ash-Sharqiya and twists around the villages of East Jerusalem. The road goes northwards up to Qalandia Airport, passes through Bitunia and ends at Beit Sheimesh area near Ben Gurion Airport. The maps clarified that the bypass road links the settlement of Jabal Abu Ghneim, south of Jerusalem, to the Jewish settlement of Ma'ale Adumim, passing through the Jerusalem-Jericho road. The schemes of the bypass road contain three tunnels each 1.8 square km2 long. By opening the road, over 700 dunums and tens of homes will be destroyed, not to mention the environmental damages caused in the area. II. Flagrant Discrimination against Jerusalemites (original inhabitants)

Palestinians have access to only 14% of the land of East Jerusalem, on which construction is allowed. However, difficult conditions are set by the Israeli government to obtain building permits. At least, 34% of the land has been confiscated to build new and expand existing Jewish settlements, and 52% declared 'green area' where construction is forbidden for Arab Palestinians. Israel has allowed for settlement construction seven times more than what is planned for Palestinians despite their desperate need for housing.

  • Confiscation of land for settlement expansion and construction;

  • Demolition of Arab houses for settlement activities;

  • Restrictions on building and renovation works;

  • High fines imposed on Palestinians for building without permits.

Palestinian Jerusalemites have for long experienced an unbearable housing crisis. Many of them are forced to build without obtaining permits from the Israeli government in order to provide shelter to their families, not to mention those who are forced to live outside the municipal boundaries of Jerusalem, due to lack of housing possibilities.

According to JCSER and the Palestinian Society for the Protection of Human Rights & the Environment (LAW), some 177 Arab houses have been demolished in Jerusalem by Israel over the past five years, in addition to issuing over 558 house demolition orders for building without permits.

Building restrictions are imposed on Palestinians in East Jerusalem, many of whom are forced to build without permits from the Israeli government, if issued, a $25,000-fee must be paid. It usually takes over a year to obtain a building permit from the Israeli government and those who build without permits are charged high fees by Israel.

Arab houses are demolished by Israel to make way for settlement activities in Jerusalem and its suburbs. The policy of house demolition, adopted by Israel since June 1967, is one form of collective punishment against Palestinians and constitutes grave violations of International Laws, especially article 33 of the 1949 Fourth Geneva Convention, which prohibits such a policy.

Restrictions are also placed on renovation works. There are 1,400 houses inside the walls of the Old City in desperate need of renovation. 356 out of 1,400 are on the verge of collapse, due to insufficient services and proper renovation, in addition to excavations carried out by the Jerusalem Municipality.

The general closure and separation policy imposed by Israel since March 1993 has caused severe damages in various sectors. The Israeli government has continued illegally and unjustly to impose exorbitant taxes on Palestinian Jerusalemites in return for poor quality services. Taxes are imposed on Palestinians without taking into consideration the different income levels and social differences between East Jerusalem and West Jerusalem. This has led to the spread of bankruptcy amongst Palestinians. There has been a 40% increase in poverty rates and 35% rise in the unemployment rate amongst Palestinians, not to mention that a number of retail shops have been forced to close down as the owners were unable to pay taxes imposed by the Jerusalem Municipality.

Palestinians unable to pay the Arnona tax are being subjected to a series of illegal and punitive measures by the Israeli government. Imprisonment and confiscation of properties is one form of measures taken against Palestinians in East Jerusalem. Although Palestinian citizens have to pay high Arnona tax, they receive poor quality services. According to JCSER, the total amount of taxes earned from Palestinian Jerusalemites exceeds 30% of the Arnona tax fund at the Jerusalem Municipality in return for only 5% of the total services provided to them. Israel's tax policy in East Jerusalem is completely racist. Taxes imposed in East Jerusalem are the same as those in West Jerusalem without taking into consideration the different income levels between East and West Jerusalem and the differences in cultural and social life that affect income levels and living patterns.

It has become familiar to see growing numbers of businesses shut down, as a result of the Israeli policy in East Jerusalem. According to a field study conducted by JCSER, 250 out of 1000 shops shut down in the Old City, due to their inability to pay taxes.

Arab East Jerusalem suffers from severe shortage of infrastructure services. Israel is tightening its control over Jerusalem and its residents in various aspects of life. On the educational level, Israel continues to impose its curriculum on schools in East Jerusalem. There is a shortage of 344 classrooms, which contribute to the deterioration of education standards compared to that of West Jerusalem.

The tourism sector has reported severe loses, as a result of the Israeli practices in Arab East Jerusalem. During the Israeli occupation, not a single hotel was built in Arab East Jerusalem. Palestinians have for long been prevented from distributing printed brochures to tourists. Instead, they are given Israeli publications, which provide incorrect and distorted facts and information about the Holy City, its history, and archeological sites. Israel has for long monopolized this industry by providing Israeli tourist guides who present distorted information about Jerusalem, its history, and its residents.

According to official Palestinian sources, the number of Arab tourist guides and tourist agencies in Jerusalem has dropped. In 1967, there were 207 tourist guides, this figure dropped to 100 in 1990, and 47 tourist agencies in 1967 dropped to 32 in 1990. The number of Arab-owned hotels in Jerusalem has dropped to 40. The ongoing closure of Jerusalem imposed since March 1993 has prevented Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip from marketing their products, such as the olivewood produced in Bethlehem and glass in Hebron. Christians constituted 72% of the total pilgrims visiting the Holy Land from all over the world, Jews 18% and Moslems 10%. People visiting the Holy City for religious reasons constituted 25% of the total pilgrims during 1994, confirming that Jerusalem is a Palestinian tourist city and that tourism is an essential sector for the Palestinian national economy. Jerusalem is a main touristic treasury for Palestinians, especially as religious tourism is one of the most ancient industries in Palestine.

The Israeli slogan 'United Jerusalem is Israel's Eternal Capital' was promoted to create the idea amongst tourists that united Jerusalem is one city and that the occupied Arab East Jerusalem is an integral part of the city. Besides promoting the slogan, Israel took a number of measures to realize this slogan and to control the Arab population in the city. These include:

  • Expropriation of Arab land and properties;

  • Unrealistic increase in the price of land;

  • Uprooting olive trees and agricultural products to pave the way for settlement construction and expansion;

  • Imposing high taxes on Palestinians;

  • Imposing difficult conditions on Palestinians to obtain building permits;

  • Placing restrictions on buildings by not exceeding certain height;

  • Placing restrictions on renovation of archeological and religious sites.

These measures contributed significantly to the deterioration in the Palestinian economy in East Jerusalem.

III. Confiscation of Citizenship Rights

Palestinian citizens are constantly harassed by the Israeli Ministry of the Interior with the aim of forcing them out of their homes and denying their basic rights to citizenship, residency, housing, medical care, work, schooling, and other rights. To achieve this, the Interior Ministry coordinates closely with other Israeli institutions, including the National Insurance Institute (NII).

Palestinian Jerusalemites are regarded as residents subject to the treatment and conditions of residency rights applied to foreigners despite their deep roots in the Holy City. Identity cards granted to Palestinian Jerusalemites provide these residents with the same status of permanent resident granted to foreigners living in Israel. Israel deals with Palestinians as immigrants living in their homes as a 'favor', not as their natural right acknowledged in international and humanitarian laws and conventions before anything else.

Israel has imposed difficult and impossible conditions on Palestinian Jerusalemites by challenging them with the burden of having to prove their 'center of life' without justification. Palestinians have to provide official documents and papers that prove their place of residence in Jerusalem for a minimum period of seven years. According to unofficial Israeli sources and human rights organizations, some 20,000 children are denied registration on their parents' ID cards, which means they are also deprived of services to which they are entitled from the National Insurance Institute. The situation became worse by the end of 1995 when the Ministry of the Interior confiscated randomly a huge quantity of ID cards from Palestinians, claiming that they were not resident inside the municipal boundaries of Jerusalem. The 1952 Law of Entry to Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem was applied according to the whims and interpretations of the Ministry of the Interior, which contradicts the articles of the law itself.

The instructions given by the Interior Ministry to Palestinians concerning requirements to prove their 'center of life' are characterized by ambiguity and vagueness. Providing incorrect information to Palestinians helps the Interior Ministry to achieve its main objectives. It also adopts several measures to control the Arab population in the city. These include confiscation of Jerusalem ID cards, its refusal to register children on their parents' ID cards, and its denial of their social services and benefits provided by the National Insurance Institute. As a result, Palestinians face numerous health, psychological and financial problems and entire families are forced to flee the city.

In accordance with Israeli residency laws adopted against Palestinian Jerusalemites, women married to non-Jerusalemites are automatically considered residents outside the 'municipal boundaries of Jerusalem' unless the National Insurance Institute proves the opposite. In order for pregnant women to obtain birth allowances (hospital expenses covered by the National Insurance Institute), their names should be registered in a hospital and periodical medical examinations must be made within the first sixth months of pregnancy, attaching two copies of the medical reports showing the progress of pregnancy.

Israeli officials, including Former Interior Minister, Natan Sharansky, and Deputy Minister in Charge of Jerusalem Affairs, Haim Ramon, have repeatedly stated that radical changes will be made in the Ministry's policy towards Arab residents. They noted that there would be an improvement in the treatment of Arab residents according to new instructions by the Interior Ministry. But practices adopted by the Ministry of the Interior and the National Insurance Institute against Arab residents contradict these statements.

JCSER confirmed that there has been no change in the treatment of Palestinian Jerusalemites by the National Insurance Institute. Arabs are humiliated and dehumanized by the Interior Ministry's employees. Bureaucratic and humiliating conditions are imposed on Arabs by challenging them with the burden of having to prove their 'center of life' within the municipal boundaries of Jerusalem. The Ministry's employees still deny that they received new instructions with regard to improving the treatment of Arab residents, however, JCSER obtained a copy of the instructions.

The instructions are summarized as follows:

  • 'According to Israeli law, any Jerusalemite whose name has been cancelled from the Jerusalem census records since 1995 until now due to moving his place of residence outside the municipal boundaries of Jerusalem for seven years or more, loses his citizenship and residency rights in Jerusalem. A person can obtain a new residency permit and can have his name registered in the Jerusalem census record only if he lives in Israel for two consecutive years upon his return to the country.'

  • 'According to Israeli law, anyone who lived abroad (outside the municipal boundaries of Jerusalem) for more than seven years and, for some reason, has not been informed by the Interior Ministry about his ID card confiscation and the cancellation of his residency permit, continues to keep his ID card and residency right.'

  • It is worth-mentioning that these instructions are the results of the case filed by a group of human rights organizations against the Interior Ministry at the Israel Supreme Court. The 'Coalition against ID Card Confiscation', of which JCSER is an affective member, was part of this group.

According to a statistical study published by Israeli Journalist Amira Hass in the Hebrew daily Ha'aretz, some 739 Jerusalem ID cards were confiscated in 1996, and 1067 in 1997; some 788 residency rights were revoked in 1998; 414 citizenship rights were revoked in 1999 and 207 in 2000. These figures confirm that confiscation of citizenship right still occurs. However, as there has not been any significant change in the policy of the Interior Minister, it can be concluded that the efforts of human rights organizations, including JCSER, were successful in restoring citizenship and residency rights to many Palestinians.

Israel publicly declares its policy that aims to maintain a Jewish presence over the Arab population in Occupied Arab Jerusalem and prevents an increase in the number of Arab citizens exceeding more than 25% of the population. Former Israeli governments have allocated huge budgets for this purpose to expedite the process of land confiscation and settlement construction in Jerusalem and its suburbs. Government committees have been formed for this purpose, including the 'Jerusalem Support Committee', headed by the Director General of the Israeli Ministry of Housing, Shlom Ghreinberg. The Committee aims to build 110,000 units in the year 2001 in its continuous effort to disrupt the balance of the demographic composition of the city in favor of Jewish settlers.

Israel's policies in the city of Jerusalem race with time in an attempt to create new facts on the ground before entering any kind of political settlement related to Jerusalem. Such polices contradict international laws and conventions and UN Security Council Resolutions, which describe Israel's policies as 'illegal and illegitimate' and constitute grave violations of international laws, according to which Jerusalem is an occupied territory. Violations committed by Israel indicate that racial discrimination is practiced against Arab residents and that Jerusalem is not united as it claims.

JCSER stresses that daily Israeli practices against Palestinians constitute grave violations of international conventions related to human rights in general and civilians under occupation in particular. Practices include:

  • Confiscation of Arab land and property;

  • Revocation of residency and citizenship rights;

  • Confiscation of Jerusalem ID cards;

  • Denial of political, civil, social and economic rights of Palestinians, including their right to residency, citizenship, housing, work, education, medical treatment, freedom of movement, freedom of worship and other rights.

Article 13 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights reads as follows, 'Every person has the right to leave any country, including his country, and to return to it.' This right has been confirmed in articles 12B & 12D of the international law pertaining to civil and political rights. According to international law, Israel is an occupying state and Jerusalem is occupied territory. Israel should abide by the articles of the international laws, including the 1949 Forth Geneva Convention, which was signed by 188 states, including the State of Israel. These articles include: 1, 22, 27, 29, 34, 47, 49, 51, 52, 55, 59, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76 & 77. International resolutions have confirmed the necessity for Israel to comply with the articles of the 1949 Fourth Geneva Convention and international laws and conventions pertaining to the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT), including Arab East Jerusalem.

Al-Aqsa Intifada

Ariel Sharon's unwelcome visit to Al-Aqsa Mosque on Thursday, 28 September 2000 accompanied by thousands of Israeli soldiers triggered off the war of mass killing practiced by the Israeli occupation authorities against the Palestinian people throughout the West Bank and Gaza Strip, including Arab East Jerusalem.

Sharon, known for initiating bloodshed and massacres, such as the massacre of Qibia and the massacres of Sabra and Shatila in Lebanon, in which thousands of Palestinians were killed, is not the only one responsible for the continued crime against the Palestinian people. Israeli Prime Minister, Ehud Barak, shares this responsibility, as he allowed Sharon with thousands of soldiers to break into the Al-Aqsa Mosque, which has a great significance in the Islamic faith. Barak, who has been awarded the largest number of medals in the history of the Israeli army, allegedly claims that Jews have rights to the Mosque. He along with his Generals supervised a Plan, named 'Field of Thorns' to invade the Palestinian self-rule areas in the West Bank and Gaza Strip with the aim of destroying the Middle East Peace Process and peace making efforts.

The Israeli war launched against the Palestinian people has not only resulted in the killing and injuring of thousands of Palestinians, many of whom will suffer permanent physical disabilities, but also produced devastating impact on various aspects of life, including human rights violations.

Fifteen Palestinian Jerusalemites were killed, five hundred and fifty six arrested, in addition to thousands injured.

Below JCSER aims to show the devastating impact of the Intifada on religious, economic, agricultural, social, educational, psychological and health aspects of every day life.

1. Religious Aspect
The Israeli occupation forces continue their closure of the Palestinian territories by transforming Palestinian villages and refugee camps into small cantons, separated from each other. The Israeli forces continuously prevent Palestinian worshippers from praying at the Al Aqsa Mosque, which is considered the third holiest Muslim shrine. Palestinian Christians are also prevented from reaching the Church of the Holy Sepulcher in the Old City of Jerusalem. These are elements of the Israeli imposed policy on Jerusalem. These restrictions not only apply to Palestinians from the West Bank and Gaza Strip, but also to the residents of Jerusalem. Palestinians of a certain age group, defined by the Israeli occupying forces, are excluded from praying at the Al Aqsa Mosque, especially on Fridays.

The Israeli occupation forces have transformed Jerusalem into military barracks, especially on Fridays. Police units and border guards are deployed in large numbers throughout Jerusalem with the aim of spreading fear amongst worshippers, and curbing the commercial activity in the city. Thousands of worshippers are forced to pray in the streets surrounded by huge numbers of Israeli soldiers and border guards. In addition, tens of military checkpoints erected between the West Bank and Jerusalem prevent Muslim worshippers, including those from areas located inside the municipal boundaries, from reaching Jerusalem. Furthermore, a number of military checkpoints have been fixed permanently with the aim of isolating the city of Jerusalem from the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

2. Economic Aspect
Since the beginning of the Intifada in late September 2000, the economic situation in the Palestinian territories has reported severe losses, estimated at millions of US dollars. The Israeli closure has had a devastating impact on the economy of East Jerusalem, despite the fact that the Israeli occupation forces have not used tanks and helicopters in the city. Israeli tanks are stationed at the main entrances of Palestinian cities and on hilltops, shelling Palestinian civilians with heavy machine guns and rockets. Jerusalem is not spared from these conditions.

The Israeli closure of the Palestinian territories has prevented some 250,000 workers from crossing the 'green line', and forced hundreds of Palestinian factories and workshops to close down their businesses. The tourism sector has suffered immensely from the current political situation. Hotels, restaurants, and souvenir shops in various parts of the Palestinian territories were forced to dismiss their employees, due to severe drop in the number of tourists visiting the area. In addition, Palestinian Jerusalemites working inside the 'green line' left their jobs or were forced to leave, as a result of the racial segregation policy adopted by the Israeli occupation forces.

3. Agricultural Aspect
The Intifada erupted at the beginning of the harvest season, during which a number of Palestinians were injured and killed while picking olives, in particular in the governorates of Nablus, Salfit and Ramallah. In addition, Israeli bulldozers uprooted thousands of olive trees and prevented Palestinian farmers from reaching their fields to pick the olives. The closure of the Palestinian territories has also prevented Palestinian farmers from marketing their agricultural products, thus causing severe losses, estimated at millions of US dollars.

4. Psychological and Educational Aspects
Education has enormously been affected by the Israeli closure of the Palestinian territories. The Israeli occupation forces tend to break into schools for military purposes. A number of schools have been shelled by live ammunition. Palestinian schoolchildren have become targets of the Israeli army. Tens of school children were intentionally shot dead by Israeli snipers upon the instructions of top Israeli officials.

The shelling of Palestinian residential areas with heavy machine guns has had a devastating psychological impact on Palestinian children. They live in a state of constant panic and fear, which has a negative impact on their performances at school. Large numbers of teachers and students are also unable to reach schools, as a result of the closure policy, causing severe disruption in the educational system.

5. Health Aspect
Palestinian hospitals suffer from severe shortage of medicine and medical supplies necessary for providing proper medical treatment to the injured. Palestinian ambulances have become targets of the Israeli snipers. The killing of a German doctor in Beit Jala while providing first aid to the injured, and the killing of an ambulance driver while trying to save the life of Mohammed Jamal Al-Dura and his father are clear examples of the danger inflicted on the Palestinian medical teams, caused by the Israeli inhuman and ruthless practices.

The Israeli occupation forces prevent ambulances from transferring the injured to hospitals for medical treatment. In addition, Israeli soldiers stationed at military checkpoints prevent ambulances from transferring sick and injured people from one city to another. Pregnant Palestinian women have also been unable to reach the hospitals to give birth because of the military checkpoints erected. Some pregnant women have been forced to give birth at military checkpoints, as they did not get permission to reach the hospital.

The number of injured exceeds the capacity of Palestinian hospitals, forcing many of the injured to suffer whilst waiting for their turn. As a result of this situation, some of the injured have to leave the hospital early before completing their medical treatment to make room for other patients.

Denying access of medical supplies to hospitals by holding them back at military checkpoints and preventing ambulances from bringing the sick and injured to hospitals for medical treatment is a crime that demands immediate local and international intervention.

JCSER Activities

Socio-Economic Study

JCSER conducted a study on the social and economic reality of Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem. The study dealt with various issues, amongst which are types and quality services provided to Arab citizens, amounts and types of taxes imposed on citizens, supported by scientific data and figures. The study aimed to research:

Field Studies and Statistics

A field study, the first of its kind, was conducted by the Center's field researchers on different types of businesses in East Jerusalem, their area, type of work and number of employees. The study showed that an estimated 25% of businesses shut down in the Old City of Jerusalem during the Israeli occupation, as a result of the economic recession and high taxes. The majority of these businesses were located in 'Aqbet Al-Khaldiah, Al-Wad Street, Al-Dabbagha, Chain Street, Al-Qattanin Market and Al-Nassarah Quarter.

According to the study, some 125 businesses with a total area of 558 square meters are still open in the neighborhood As-Sharaf in the Old City. Some of these businesses have been established since 1930. The owners have been exposed to frequent attempts by Israel to force them out of the city and have their real estates sold. Despite this, they are steadfast in their homeland, which they inherited from their fathers and grandfathers.

International Activities

JCSER participated in a number of international conferences and meetings with the aim of disclosing human rights violations committed by Israel against the Palestinian people in general and Arab citizens in occupied Jerusalem in particular and their suffering. Such practices constitute grave violations of international laws and conventions and UN Security Council Resolutions pertaining to the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT), including Arab East Jerusalem.

JCSER conducted scientific studies and research dealing with Israeli practices and violations in East Jerusalem. It presented a number of papers and proposals outlining measures that should be taken by the international community, its organizations and institutions to end human rights violations committed by Israel against Palestinian Jerusalemites. These papers aimed to:

  • Put an end to the Israeli violations in Jerusalem;

  • Protect Palestinian civilians under Israeli military occupation;

  • Force Israel as an occupying power to respect and comply with International Laws, including the 1949 Fourth Geneva Convention;

  • Activate international support for the rights of the Palestinian people in accordance with international legitimate resolutions.

On 4 September 1999, a conference was held in Athens with the aim of obtaining international support for the rights of the Palestinian people. A speech was delivered by the Center's Director, Mr. Ziad Al-Hammouri, during which he gave a historic review of the situation in Jerusalem before and after the Israeli occupation in June 1967, supported by figures and studies. In his speech, Mr. Hammouri strongly condemned the unilateral annexation of East Jerusalem a few days after its occupation. He noted that since 1967, Israel has changed the landmarks of Jerusalem. Entire Arab neighborhoods were completely destroyed by the Israeli occupation authorities, such as Al-Sharaf and Al-Magharbeh in the Old City. Names of streets were changed and entire West Bank areas were confiscated to expand the municipal boundaries of Jerusalem whose total area was 1,500 hectares before the Israeli occupation in 1967. Following the expansion decision, the area of Jerusalem increased to 18,000 hectares. Procedures are currently underway to annex the Jewish settlement of Ma'ale Adumim within the 'Greater Jerusalem Plan.'

Since the annexation of East Jerusalem in June 1967, Jewish settlement activities have been intensified in occupied Arab Jerusalem. The number of Jewish settlers in East Jerusalem exceeds the number of Arabs, although there were few Jewish residents before the Israeli occupation of Jerusalem. Following the annexation of Jerusalem in June 1967, the Arab population constituted 25.8% of the total population in East and West Jerusalem. Now, the Arab population exceeds 30%, due to high reproduction rates amongst Arabs.

In his speech, Mr. Hammouri referred to the ongoing closure of Jerusalem imposed by Israel on 30 March 1993. He pointed out that Palestinians from the West Bank and Gaza Strip have been prevented from entering Jerusalem unless they obtain special permits from the Israeli government. The closure has had a devastating impact on the economy of East Jerusalem and thus on the Palestinian economy in general. Hundreds of businesses inside and outside the Old City were forced to close down, as a result of the economic recession and high taxes imposed by Israel. An estimated 25% of the businesses in the Old City of Jerusalem closed down, as the owners were unable to pay high taxes.

Israel's practices primarily aim at encouraging the immigration of Palestinian Jerusalemites out of their homes to make way for the Judaization of Jerusalem. Israeli military forces have confiscated 34% of the land of Jerusalem to build new and expand existing Jewish settlements, and 52% has been designated as 'green area' on which construction is not allowed for Palestinians, while it remains a strategic reserve for the construction and expansion of settlements. Palestinians have only 14% of the land of Jerusalem where construction is allowed. This area was already overcrowded before the city came under the Israeli occupation in June 1967.

Mr. Hammouri also referred to the severe drop in the number of buses operating between the West Bank and Gaza Strip from 503 to 72. The permanent unemployment rate amongst Palestinians in Arab East Jerusalem has reached 35%.

In his speech, Mr. Hammouri noted that Arab Jerusalem is not only a piece of land for the Palestinian people, but also a religious and cultural history. If the Palestinian issue is the core of the Arab-Israeli conflict, Jerusalem is the heart of the Palestinian issue, refugees, Jewish settlements and borders.

Disclosure of Israeli Violations in East Jerusalem Before the International Investigation Committee

During a session held in Egypt on 18-20 May 2000, a delegate from JCSER gave a testimony before the UN International Committee for the Investigation of the Israeli violations in the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT). The delegate outlined the most prominent practices and violations committed by Israel against Palestinian residents of East Jerusalem, practices which result in the denial of their civil, political, social and economic rights in Jerusalem. The outcomes of Israel's policies of ethnic cleansing, house demolition, and citizens' denial of residency and citizenship rights in Jerusalem were also referred to. Furthermore, the illegal policy of ID card confiscation and citizens' denial of health insurance and allowances from the National Insurance Institute (NII) were mentioned. JCSER also noted that the policy of ID card confiscation and other violations confirm Israel's frequent attempts to impose new facts on the ground with the aim of 'Judaizing' the Holy City, changing its landmarks, and emptying the city of its original inhabitants. JCSER's delegate also noted that imposing exorbitant amounts of Arnona tax in an illegal measure serve the same aim as the confiscation of properties and ID cards, namely to force the Arab population out of their homes.

In his testimony, the delegate referred to the Israeli settlement policy in East Jerusalem. He mentioned the confiscation of thousands of dunums to build new Jewish settlements in Ras Al-Amud, Jabal Abu Ghneim, and Abu Dis, as well as the expansion of existing Jewish settlements in the area known as the 'Good Samaritan Inn'. This confirms Israel's frequent attempts to Judaize the Holy City, to empty the city of its original inhabitants, and to impose new facts on the ground before entering the final status negotiations with the Palestinians.

The UN International Investigation Committee consists of three ambassadors from Sri Lanka, Malysia and Senigal, and is headed by the Ambassador of Sri Lanka, Mr. John De Saram. The committee members are forbidden from entering the Occupied Palestinian Territories and the Golan Heights, occupied by Israel in June 1967.

Press Releases & Public Awareness

During the period covered in this report, JCSER issued some forty-five statements and press releases dealing with Israeli practices and violations committed against Palestinians. Statements dealt with citizens' suffering in regaining their Jerusalem ID cards and obtaining family reunification permits from the Israeli Interior Ministry. The process of having a family reunification application officially approved by the Ministry takes over four years. A statement was issued concerning JCSER's success in obtaining three family reunification permits from the Interior Ministry.

Other statements dealt with the arbitrary and abusive measures taken by the Israeli government with regard to holding back allowances and benefits to which citizens are entitled from the National Insurance Institute, due to their failure to pay the Arnona tax on time. Statements also revealed the illegality of the procedures adopted by the Jerusalem Municipality with regard to issuing unfair court judgements against citizens by requesting them to pay exorbitant amounts of Arnona tax. A statement was released on the revocation of unfair court rulings issued against Palestinian citizens.

Statements unveiled methods adopted by the Israeli Interior Ministry with regard to canceling names of Palestinian Jerusalemites from the Jerusalem census records, which offer health and National Insurance, thus denying their right to free medical treatment. A citizen was forced to pay his medical treatment expenses at the Sha'ari Zedeq Medical Center in Jerusalem, because his name was cancelled from the health insurance records without his knowledge.

Strongly-worded statements condemned the process of breaking into Arab houses and confiscating their properties by the Bailiff Office in accordance with court decisions. Israeli police units and border guards accompanied by an armed unit from the Jerusalem Municipality broke into Jawad Badirah's house in the Wadi Al-Joz neighborhood in Jerusalem on 21 February 2000.

JCSER issued statements with the aim of raising public awareness concerning their rights at the Jerusalem Municipality, the National Insurance Institute and the Bailiff Office. Public notices were published in the Arabic daily Al-Quds, dated 2nd and 4th April 2000 regarding the right of citizens to free education.

The Center held dozens of field meetings with a number of merchants and citizens to discuss methods to deal with the procedures taken by the Bailiff Office. A meeting was held at the Charitable Society in Beit Safafa concerning this issue. Another meeting was held with the Old City's merchants whose businesses were shut down by the Israeli police. During the meeting, attendants discussed this issue, which resulted in huge economic and financial losses, especially in the tourism sector. Various points of view were exchanged with regard to future coordination in confronting Israel's arbitrary polices in the city. A field meeting was also held with the locals of the neighborhood of At-Tur to discuss the arrest of a number of Arab citizens for raising Palestinian flags during the historic visit of Pope John Paul II to the Holy Land in March 2000. Other various activities carried out by the Center were also discussed.

Tens of individual and group meetings were held to discuss issues related to the Arnona tax, traffic offences and social income insurance. Group meetings were held with business owners highlighting the fact that Palestinian Jerusalemites are facing numerous problems that require immediate intervention by local and international human rights organizations.

Click here to continue


All rights reserved, Copyright © 2002 Jerusalem Center for Social & Economic Rights 2001.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Designed By: 
Mutasem A.Hamoudeh